orca vs crystl, compared

Checked November 15, 2026. Every Orca fact below was read from orca.dev, its docs, its GitHub repository and the GitHub API on that date, against v1.4.259. Orca ships a release most days. Re-check anything you are about to depend on. Disclosure: crystl is our product.

Orca asks you to move into a new IDE. crystl asks you to change nothing. You keep your editor, your agents keep their own interfaces, and crystl runs them side by side across every project, on your Mac or on any server you can SSH into. When one of them needs you, the approval or the question comes to you on a card, wherever you are.

Both have worktrees, a browser for the site you are building, and switching between agent accounts. They differ in where the work happens and how it reaches you. If you are on Windows or Linux, or you want an editor and a diff reviewer in the same app, Orca is the better fit.

what Orca is

Orca is made by Stably AI, a Y Combinator company in San Francisco. Its homepage says "Ship 100x with the agent IDE". It is MIT licensed and has about 125,000 stars on GitHub.

at a glance

ProductWhere agents runOn a remote serverApprovalsPlatformsCost
Orcayour machine, an SSH host, a remote Orca server, or a cloud VM you bringinstalls its own server and a Node runtime on the hostanswered in its chat transcriptmacOS, Windows, Linux; iOS and Android companion in betafree, MIT
crystl, freeyour Mac, or any server you can SSH intoneeds only ssh and the agent on the servera card on your desktop and phone, from any projectmacOS, iPhone over Wi-Fifree
crystl guildsamesamesame, plus orchestrators and DeusmacOS, iPhone from anywhere$170/year or $18/month

Orca's cloud VM option is marked experimental, and you bring the provider: Vercel Sandbox, Fly, Modal, Docker or an SSH box. An enterprise offering exists, with no public prices.

what needs you comes to you

This is the biggest difference in daily use. In Orca, an agent's permission request is a card in that agent's chat transcript. You answer it when you open that worktree. Orca's notifications fire when an agent finishes a turn.

In crystl, when Claude Code, Codex or Kimi Code wants to run something, the request shows up as a floating card on your desktop and on your phone, from whichever project it came from. You approve it on the card without going to find the shard. Questions and finished tasks arrive the same way, and the shard's tab changes color. Theagent activity panel lists who needs a person, who has stalled and what each agent has cost, across every gem at once. With eleven agents in four projects, you stop checking on them and answer when one asks.

remote servers: nothing to install

Orca's SSH mode installs its own server on the host the first time you connect, with a Node runtime it downloads and keeps updated, in ~/.orca-remote. Its docs list what stops that: an unsupported OS or CPU, a home folder that does not allow running programs, or an SSH server that refuses port forwarding.

crystl puts nothing on the server. It needs ssh and the agent you want to run. In the New Gem panel you switch the location from this mac toremote and type user@host or a name from your SSH config. You answer any password or 2FA prompt in the terminal, and then crystl creates the folder on the server, runs git init, and writes your starter files, agent instructions and MCP config there. The gem gets an ssh mark in the sidebar. After that:

  • New shards reconnect for you, reusing the login, in the folder you were in.
  • Worktrees live on the server. Merge, rebase and close all run there.
  • Approvals come back to your Mac through a tunnel crystl sets up, as the same cards.
  • A dropped connection is one click. The band under the shard offersreattach.
  • Files move both ways. Drag a file into a remote shard to copy it up; click a remote path to open it locally.

The details are in remote SSH sessions.

what both have

  • A browser for the site you are building. Orca has an embedded Chromium with a design mode. crystl's web view sits beside the shard: click an element, type what is wrong, and the agent gets a picture of it, its selector, its HTML and styles, and your note. A strip counts console errors and failed requests and sends them to the agent in one click, and each project keeps its own logins.
  • More than one agent account. Orca switches the active Claude Code or Codex login in one click. crystl runs several logins side by side: type claude@work in one shard and plain claude in the next. The usage meter shows each account's limits, and a shard stalled on a limit gets a nudge button the moment it resets. Seeaccounts.
  • Worktrees per agent, and orchestration where one agent starts others.

crystl

A gem is a project and a shard is a session inside it. Beyond the above:

  • Any agent, untouched. Claude Code, Codex, Antigravity CLI, Kimi Code, aider, or a wrapper you wrote, each in its own interface with its own shortcuts.
  • Deus. On guild, an orchestrator in each project hands work to workers and merges it back, and Deus manages those orchestrators across every project. Agents start out knowing the CLI, so you ask in plain words.
  • Models you host. Ollama, vLLM, LM Studio and llama.cpp, next to the hosted agents, including from a remote server. Orca's docs do not mention local models. Seeopen models.
  • The write guard. An isolated shard's file writes that land outside its own worktree are denied before the tool runs.
  • A shared task list. The workbench is a WORKBENCH.md file in the project that you and your agents both edit.
  • Sequences. Staged jobs that run on a schedule, on a file change or by hand. See sequences.
  • A real iPhone app. Approve tools, answer questions, steer agents and talk to them from the phone, free over Wi-Fi and from anywhere on guild.

Where it falls short: crystl is macOS only, and the phone app is iPhone only. It is closed source. It has no editor, no inline diff review and no pull request flow, so you keep your editor and open PRs yourself. Orchestration and phone access from anywhere cost$170 a year. The terminal, SSH, isolated shards, approvals, the web view and history are free.

Pick crystl if you are on a Mac, you want to keep your editor, and you run agents in many projects or on servers you would rather not install things on.

orca

Where it is ahead:

  • Review and pull requests. Notes on exact changed lines go to the agent. Commit messages and PRs are drafted from the diff, and failing checks or review comments go back to an agent. GitHub, Linear and Jira issues show up as tasks.
  • An editor in the app, with chat and terminal views you can switch between.
  • Platforms. macOS, Windows and Linux, plus a headless Linux server.
  • Mobile emulators. Orca drives the iOS Simulator and Android emulator.
  • Free and open source.

What to hold against it:

  • Approvals wait in the transcript. Notifications cover finished turns.
  • The phone app is a beta remote control. Orca's docs say it is "intentionally not a full editor", the desktop has to be running and reachable, and Android is an APK you install by hand.
  • Telemetry. Usage events are sent with a random install ID, with file contents, prompts and agent output excluded. You turn it off in settings or withDO_NOT_TRACK=1.
  • It replaces your editor. If you like the one you have, much of Orca goes unused.

Pick Orca if you want one free app to replace your editor, terminal and review tool, or you work on Windows or Linux.

how to choose in one pass

  • You are on Windows or Linux: Orca.
  • You want an all-in-one agent IDE with diff review: Orca.
  • It has to be open source: Orca.
  • You want to keep your editor: crystl.
  • You want approvals from every project to come to you, on the desktop and the phone: crystl.
  • You work on servers and do not want to install anything on them: crystl.
  • You want to run local or self-hosted models: crystl.

further reading